One Pro Inspections · Learn

Learn › Become a NY Home Inspector › Week 4

Week 4 · Module 1: Structure, exterior & roof

Structure: beams, posts, joists and sills

15 min reading

Free supplemental study material. Not a NYS DOS-approved qualifying course and does not count toward the required 140 hours.
Listen to this lesson
English
Español

AI-narrated. A recording by Onelfri is coming soon.

Read the narration script

Once you're done with the foundation walls, look up. The framing over your head carries the house: sills on the foundation, girders and posts down the middle, joists across. In older NYC homes it has usually been cut, patched and added to more than once. Your job is to spot what's damaged, what's been cut too much and what's been patched badly.

Terms in this lesson: Joists · Girder (main beam) · Sill plate · Ledger strip

How the load gets down

Follow the load path from top to bottom. Joists carry the floor and rest on the sill plate at the foundation and on a girder (main beam) in the middle. The girder rests on posts or columns, and those sit on footings. If any link is damaged or missing, the load has to go somewhere else.

What to look at:

  • Sill plates. Probe them with a screwdriver or awl where you can reach, especially near stoops, porches and attached garages. Soft wood means rot or insect damage.
  • Girders and beams. Sagging, cracks, rot, and how much of the beam is actually sitting on its support.
  • Posts and columns. Leaning, rusted bases, or temporary jack posts left in place as a permanent fix.
  • Joists. Cracks, sags, rot, and how they're attached to the girder.

Connections: where things fail

Joists can be attached to a girder in a few ways: resting on top of it, set into notches, hung in metal hangers, or sitting on a ledger strip nailed along the side of the girder. Ledger strips are the weakest of these, because the nails carry the load. Look for split ledgers, nails pulling out and joists that have dropped.

Also watch for sistered joists (a new joist fastened alongside a damaged one). That's a common repair. Note it, and look at the old joist to see why it needed help.

Basement posts that wobble, have no visible attachment at the top or bottom, or rest on a thin slab with no footing you can see are worth noting. You can't see the footing under a slab, so say so.

Notching and boring: the code numbers

Diagram of a joist divided into thirds: notches allowed only in the outer thirds, no notches in the middle third, end notches up to one quarter of the depth, holes up to one third of the depth and at least two inches from the edges
Illustration. Based on 2020 NYS Residential Code R502.8. A reference for newer work; older homes were built under older rules.

Plumbers, electricians and HVAC installers cut framing all the time. The 2020 NYS Residential Code (same text as the IRC) sets the limits for solid-lumber joists, rafters and beams in R502.8.1:

  • Notches: no deeper than 1/6 of the member's depth, no longer than 1/3 of the depth, and never in the middle third of the span.
  • End notches: no deeper than 1/4 of the depth.
  • Holes: no larger than 1/3 of the depth, and not closer than 2 inches to the top or bottom edge, another hole, or a notch.

For studs, R602.6 says studs in exterior or bearing walls can be notched up to 25% of their width, and nonbearing studs up to 40%. Holes can be up to 60% of the stud width, with at least 5/8 inch to the edge; in exterior or bearing walls, studs bored over 40% and up to 60% must be doubled.

Trusses, engineered lumber and what to write

Never cut trusses. R502.8.2 prohibits cuts, notches and holes in trusses, I-joists and other engineered wood unless the manufacturer allows it or a design professional has accounted for it. In an attic or basement, look for cut truss webs, missing or loose metal gusset plates, and I-joists with holes cut through the flanges.

Older homes weren't built to today's code, so don't fail them on code. Instead, describe what's there: "Joist notched at the bottom edge near mid-span for a drain line." Then explain why it matters (a cut in the middle of the span weakens the joist where it works hardest) and recommend evaluation by a qualified contractor or structural engineer.

Don't ever miss: cracked or sagging joists, improperly cut members, cut trusses, rotted sills, and temporary supports left as a permanent fix.

Describe this defect

Illustration of a joist divided into thirds with notching and boring limits
Hypothetical scenario (illustration, not a real house): in an unfinished basement, a floor joist under the bathroom has been notched about a third of the way up from its bottom edge near the middle of its span, where a drain line passes through. The joist shows a split running along the grain from the notch.

Write it up the way it would go in a report: what it is, where it is, why it matters, and what you'd recommend. It stays in this browser; nothing is sent anywhere.

Check yourself: 5 questions

Pick an answer to see instantly whether it's right. Your answers are saved in this browser.

1. Under 2020 NYS Residential Code R502.8.1, where may a solid-lumber joist NOT be notched?

2. Under R502.8.1, the largest hole bored in a joist may be:

3. Which joist-to-girder connection is usually the weakest?

4. Under R502.8.2, cutting a truss web is:

5. Under R602.6, a stud in a bearing wall may be notched up to:

Key takeaways

  • Follow the load path: joists, sills, girders, posts and footings.
  • Probe sill plates where you can reach, especially near stoops and garages.
  • Ledger strips are the weakest joist-to-girder connection; check for splitting and dropped joists.
  • R502.8.1: no notches in the middle third; notches max 1/6 depth; end notches max 1/4; holes max 1/3 depth, 2 inches from edges.
  • Never cut trusses or engineered lumber without manufacturer or design-professional approval (R502.8.2).

Finished the lesson? Mark it complete to save your progress in this browser.

Practice questions →

Sources